Obsidian LiveSync vs Syncthing

Editor take

Choose Obsidian LiveSync for notes merged for you and for a vault copy on a server you run. Choose Syncthing for any folder, not only a vault, and for send only folders that never take changes back.

Editor

Where they differ

Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.

Obsidian LiveSync

Where Obsidian LiveSync is stronger

  • Conflicts merged for youSimple conflicting edits are merged automatically; Syncthing keeps the losing version as a .sync-conflict file and leaves the merge to you.1
  • The vault lives on your serverNotes sit in CouchDB, or in S3-compatible storage such as S3, R2 or MinIO, so they are there when no device is; Syncthing's copies exist only on the devices it syncs between.2

Syncthing

Where Syncthing is stronger

  • Any folder, not just a vaultSyncs whatever folder you share, with no Obsidian plugin and no Obsidian version to match; LiveSync works inside an Obsidian vault and needs 1.7.2 or later.3
  • Send only and receive only foldersA folder can push changes without accepting any, or take them without writing back; a LiveSync vault syncs in both directions.4

Obsidian LiveSync vs Syncthing: specs side by side

Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.

Spec
PriceFreeFree
LicenceMITMPL-2.0
Web UI–Yes
Windows–Yes
macOS–Yes
Linux–Yes
DockerYesYes
Linux package–Yes
Windows–Yes
macOS–Yes
Obsidian pluginYes–
Tech stackCouchDBGo
Docker Containers2 (app, CouchDB)1 (app only)
DatabaseCouchDBSQLite
Architecturex86 + ARMx86 + ARM

Common questions

Sources: Obsidian LiveSync docs and Syncthing docs.

Updated