Mail Archiver vs Open Archiver
Editor take
Choose Mail Archiver for single sign-on and for retention rules without the Enterprise edition. Choose Open Archiver for Workspace and Microsoft 365 connectors and for S3-compatible storage.
Where they differ
Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.
Mail Archiver
Where Mail Archiver is stronger
- Single sign-on in the free installSwitch on OIDC to sign in through Entra ID, Authelia or another provider; Open Archiver keeps single sign-on in Enterprise.1
- Retention rules in the free installPer account, delete from the mail server and the local archive after separate day counts; Open Archiver keeps retention policies in Enterprise.2
- MCP server for AI agentsOff until you enable it, read-only MCP tools search the archive with scoped per-user API keys.3
Open Archiver
Where Open Archiver is stronger
- Google Workspace connectorReads Workspace mailboxes through a service account, set up by a Super Administrator, rather than IMAP app passwords.4
- S3-compatible storageKeep the archive on local disk or in an S3-compatible bucket.5
- Outlook PST importImports .pst files alongside mbox and zipped EML; Mail Archiver's import docs list neither PST nor Thunderbird.6
Mail Archiver vs Open Archiver: specs side by side
Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Licence | GPL-3.0 | AGPL-3.0 |
| Storage support | Local | Local, S3 |
| Deduplication | Not applicable | Yes |
| Web UI | Yes | Yes |
| Docker | Yes | Yes |
| Tech stack | .NET | Node |
| Docker Containers | 2 (app, Postgres) | 5 (app + Postgres, Valkey, Meilisearch, Tika) |
| Database | Postgres | Postgres |
| Minimum hardware | Not stated | 4 GB RAM |
| Architecture | x86 + ARM | x86 + ARM |
Common questions
Is the Open Archiver audit log free?
No. The audit log, legal holds, retention policies and single sign-on are part of the Enterprise edition, which costs €65 per seat for one to four seats, as a one-time payment. Mail Archiver includes retention policies, access logging and OIDC login in the free install.
Which one imports Outlook PST files?
Open Archiver imports .pst files, mbox and zipped EML, and connects to JMAP. Mail Archiver's import docs list mbox and zipped EML, and it connects to IMAP, Microsoft 365 and Outlook.com.
Can either store the archive in S3?
Open Archiver can write to local disk or any S3-compatible bucket. Mail Archiver keeps its archive in PostgreSQL, and its setup reference has no S3 setting.
Sources: Mail Archiver docs and Open Archiver docs.