Bichon vs Open Archiver
Editor take
Choose Bichon for one binary with no external database and for Thunderbird profile import. Choose Open Archiver for Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 connectors and for S3-compatible storage.
Where they differ
Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.
Bichon
Where Bichon is stronger
- One binary, no databaseThe search index, blobs and metadata are embedded, so there is no PostgreSQL, Valkey or Meilisearch to run.1
- Per-account download schedulesEach account gets its own cron schedule; Open Archiver sets one SYNC_FREQUENCY for the whole install.2
- Thunderbird profile importReads a Thunderbird profile directory directly, alongside mbox, PST and EML imports.3
Open Archiver
Where Open Archiver is stronger
- Workspace and Microsoft 365 connectorsA Workspace service account and a Microsoft Graph app registration pull mail without IMAP passwords; an admin sets each up.4
- S3-compatible storageKeep the archive on local disk or in an S3-compatible bucket.5
- Per-email integrity reportsHashes each message and attachment at ingestion and checks the files still match; Bichon's integrity checks are Pro.6
Bichon vs Open Archiver: specs side by side
Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Licence | AGPL-3.0 | AGPL-3.0 |
| Storage support | Local | Local, S3 |
| Deduplication | Yes | Yes |
| Web UI | Yes | Yes |
| Docker | Yes | Yes |
| Linux package | Yes | – |
| Windows | Yes | – |
| macOS | Yes | – |
| Tech stack | Rust | Node |
| Docker Containers | 1 (app only) | 5 (app + Postgres, Valkey, Meilisearch, Tika) |
| Database | file only | Postgres |
| Minimum hardware | Not stated | 4 GB RAM |
| Architecture | x86 + ARM | x86 + ARM |
Common questions
Which one has Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 connectors?
Open Archiver. Its Google Workspace connector uses a service account and its Microsoft 365 connector uses the Graph API, and an administrator sets up each. Bichon downloads mail over IMAP only, with a password or OAuth 2.0 login.
Does Bichon need a database?
No. Its index, blobs and metadata are embedded in the binary. Open Archiver's docs have it run with PostgreSQL, Valkey (Redis) and Meilisearch.
Where can each store the archive?
Bichon keeps its live data on a local disk, because its docs warn that network filesystems can corrupt the index; its built-in backup can write to S3 or a directory. Open Archiver stores the archive on local disk or in an S3-compatible bucket.
Can both check the archive has not changed?
Open Archiver stores a hash for each message and attachment at ingestion and reports whether the files still match. Bichon dedupes by content hash, and its integrity checks are part of the paid Pro edition.
Sources: Bichon docs and Open Archiver docs.