Backrest vs borgmatic
Editor take
Choose Backrest for a browser that browses and restores snapshots, and for schedules it runs itself. Choose borgmatic for database dumps before each archive and for one YAML file you can version.
Where they differ
Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.
Backrest
Where Backrest is stronger
- Snapshots in a browserBrowse every snapshot and restore a single file or folder from the dashboard; borgmatic restores from the command line with borgmatic extract.1
- Schedules it runs itselfPlans carry their own cron schedule and retention; borgmatic is a one-shot command, so cron or a systemd timer has to call it.2
borgmatic
Where borgmatic is stronger
- Database dumps before the archiveDumps Postgres, MySQL, MariaDB, MongoDB, SQLite, InfluxDB and OpenLDAP first, so the archive holds a clean copy; Backrest expects a hook you write.3
- One YAML file for everythingRepositories, sources, retention and checks live in one file you can version and copy to a new host; Backrest keeps its plans in the app.4
Backrest vs borgmatic: specs side by side
Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free | Free |
| Licence | GPL-3.0 | GPL-3.0 |
| Concurrent backups | Sequential / locked | Sequential / locked |
| Storage support | Local, SFTP, S3, B2, rclone | Local, SSH |
| Notifications | Discord, Slack, Gotify, Shoutrrr, Healthchecks | Apprise, Healthchecks, ntfy, Pushover, Uptime Kuma, Zabbix |
| Deduplication | Yes (per repository) | Yes (per repository) |
| Web UI | Yes | – |
| Docker | Yes | Yes |
| Linux package | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | – |
| macOS | Yes | Yes |
| Tech stack | Go | Python |
| Docker Containers | 1 (app only) | 1 (app only) |
| Database | SQLite | none |
| Architecture | x86 + ARM | x86 + ARM |
Common questions
Do I need Borg for borgmatic?
Yes. borgmatic works out the Borg commands from your config and runs them, so Borg has to be installed on every machine it backs up. Backrest needs only Restic, and it downloads a verified build when it has no usable one.
Can borgmatic back up a database?
Yes. It dumps Postgres, MySQL, MariaDB, MongoDB, SQLite, InfluxDB and OpenLDAP before the archive is made, plus Btrfs, LVM and ZFS snapshots. Backrest leaves that to a pre-backup hook you write yourself.
Which one reports a failed run?
Both. Backrest posts to Discord, Slack, Gotify, Shoutrrr and Healthchecks from its hooks. Borgmatic pings Healthchecks, Uptime Kuma, ntfy, Pushover, Apprise, Zabbix and others, and can run a command on error.
Can I diff my backup setup before a change?
With borgmatic, yes: the whole setup sits in one YAML file, so a change is a line in a diff and a copy to a new host replays every job. Backrest stores its plans in a config file the browser manages, so the comparison is between pages in the UI.
Sources: Backrest site and borgmatic docs.