Proxmox Backup Server vs UrBackup

Editor take

Choose Proxmox Backup Server for chunk-level dedupe in a datastore and for pulling one file out of a VM backup. Choose UrBackup for bare-metal restores from a USB stick and for backups of Windows and macOS PCs.

Editor

Where they differ

Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.

Proxmox Backup Server

Where Proxmox Backup Server is stronger

  • Chunk-level dedupe in a datastoreBackups split into fixed or variable-size chunks, and a datastore reuses a chunk across snapshots; UrBackup dedupes whole files across clients.1
  • One file out of a VM backupA snapshot catalog and recovery shell pull single files or folders from a backup; UrBackup extracts files from its file backups.2
  • Optional encryption before uploadWith client-side encryption on, AES-256-GCM runs on the client and the server cannot read the data; UrBackup's manual says local-network transfer is unencrypted.3

UrBackup

Where UrBackup is stronger

  • Restore a dead PC from USBThe project ships a restore USB stick that boots a machine and writes an image back to its disk; PBS has no client for Windows or macOS PCs.4
  • Clients for Windows and macOSClients run on Windows, macOS and Linux machines; the Proxmox Backup Server client works on Linux systems only, so a physical Windows or Mac PC is out of its reach.5
  • Images in VHD(X) files Windows can openImage backups land in a standard VHD(X) file, or raw on btrfs, ZFS, ReFS or XFS; PBS keeps chunks in its own datastore format.6

Proxmox Backup Server vs UrBackup: specs side by side

Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.

Spec
PriceFree + PaidFree
LicenceAGPL-3.0AGPL-3.0
Concurrent backupsLock-freeLock-free
Storage supportLocal, S3Local
NotificationsEmail, Gotify, WebhooksEmail
DeduplicationGlobal (across machines)Global (across machines)
Web UIYesYes
Windows–Yes
macOS–Yes
Linux–Yes
Docker–Yes
Linux packageYesYes
Windows–Yes
ISOYes–
Proxmox VEYes–
FreeBSD–Yes
Tech stackRustC++
Docker ContainersNone – runs locally1 (app only)
Minimum hardware2 cores · 2 GB RAM · 8 GBNot stated
ArchitectureWorth checking: x86 onlyAdvantage: x86 + ARM

Common questions

Sources: Proxmox Backup Server docs and UrBackup docs.

Updated