Frameleaf vs Immich

Editor take

Choose Frameleaf for pets in face groups and for a photo and video editor on your server. Choose Immich for a partner's photos in your timeline and for a longer release history.

Editor

Where they differ

Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.

Frameleaf

Where Frameleaf is stronger

  • Pets in the face groupsGives cats and dogs their own pages in the face groups, separate from people; Immich's docs answer no to animal recognition.1
  • A photo editor with versionsDevelops RAW files, applies masks and keeps saved versions beside the original; Immich's editor crops, rotates and mirrors only.2
  • Studio, a video editorCuts clips from the library on a timeline with colour grading, audio tracks and captions from speech; Immich plays and transcodes video but has no editor.3

Immich

Where Immich is stronger

  • A partner's photos in your timelinePartner sharing puts another account's photos into your main timeline; Frameleaf gives a partner their own copy of the library instead.4
  • Release history to lean onPublished upgrade notes and a compatibility policy at major versions; Frameleaf is young and its README warns of beta bugs and breaking changes.5

Frameleaf vs Immich: specs side by side

Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.

Spec
PriceFree + PaidFree
LicenceAGPL-3.0AGPL-3.0
Web UIYesYes
iOSYesYes
AndroidYesYes
WindowsYes–
macOSYes–
LinuxYes–
DockerYesYes
Linux packageYes–
Tech stackNodeNode
Docker Containers4 (app + LAN discovery, Machine learning, Postgres)4 (app + Machine learning, Valkey, Postgres)
DatabasePostgresPostgres
Minimum hardware2 cores · 6 GB RAM2 cores · 6 GB RAM
Architecturex86 + ARMx86 + ARM

Common questions

Do both back up phones?

Yes. Both ship iPhone and Android apps that upload the camera roll to your server and keep the originals on your own disks.

Sources: Frameleaf docs and Immich docs.

Updated