Frameleaf vs Immich
Editor take
Pick Immich for most households. Choose Frameleaf if you want photo editing and video tools on the same server and can live with beta software.
Pros and cons
Each app's own strengths and weaknesses, plus the specs where Frameleaf and Immich differ.
Frameleaf
Pros
- Faces and pets recognised locally
- Phone backup for the family
- Edits keep the original
- Video editor inside the library
- Originals stay as plain files
Cons
- Remote access needs a $9.99/mo Cloud plan
- Postgres database to back up
- Still in beta, bugs expected
Immich
Pros
- Automatic phone backup
- Shared timeline for the household
- Face grouping and smart search
- Partner and shared albums
- Completely free
Cons
- Deleting a user erases their photos
- No plugin system
- Upgrades can ship breaking changes
Frameleaf vs Immich: specs side by side
Every spec for both apps in one table. Values in bold are where one app has the edge, and amber ones are worth a second look before you install.
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free + Paid | Advantage: Free |
| Licence | AGPL-3.0 | AGPL-3.0 |
| Web UI | Yes | Yes |
| iOS | Yes | Yes |
| Android | Yes | Yes |
| Windows | Yes | – |
| macOS | Yes | – |
| Linux | Yes | – |
| Docker | Yes | Yes |
| Linux package | Yes | – |
| Tech stack | Node | Node |
| Docker Containers | 4 (app + LAN discovery, Machine learning, Postgres) | 4 (app + Machine learning, Valkey, Postgres) |
| Database | Postgres | Postgres |
| Minimum hardware | 2 cores · 6 GB RAM | 2 cores · 6 GB RAM |
| Architecture | x86 + ARM | x86 + ARM |
Common questions
Is Frameleaf a fork of Immich?
No. Frameleaf is its own server, and its docs include a guide for moving an Immich library over. Its compose file still reads the old Immich project name and version variable, which is what carries an existing stack across.
Do both back up phones?
Yes. Immich and Frameleaf both ship iPhone and Android apps that upload the camera roll to your server and keep the originals on your own disks.
Which one needs less RAM?
Neither is light. Immich lists 2 cores and 6 GB, Frameleaf lists the same, and both can run with machine learning off on a 4 GB server, which costs you face groups and smart search.
Is either one paid?
Both servers are free and open source under AGPL-3.0. Immich locks no features behind payment, and its product keys are optional support for development; Frameleaf charges from $9.99/mo for Frameleaf Cloud, which adds remote access, off-site backup and the TV apps.
Sources: Frameleaf docs and Immich docs. Versions checked: Frameleaf 1.2.3.
Updated