Koel vs Melarka

Editor take

Choose Koel for browser uploads and for podcasts and radio in one player. Choose Melarka for native phone apps with an offline cache and YouTube downloads.

Editor

Where they differ

Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.

Koel

Where Koel is stronger

  • Upload straight from the browserDrag files into the web UI and they join the library. Melarka reads the music folder you already have and adds more from YouTube.1
  • Podcasts and radio in one playerKoel serves podcasts and radio stations next to your albums. Melarka's extra sources are YouTube channels, videos and previews.2
  • Speaks SubsonicExisting music apps such as Feishin and Symfonium connect to it. Melarka ships its own web app, Android APK and iPhone app.3

Melarka

Where Melarka is stronger

  • Native phone apps with offline cacheThe Android app is a signed APK on every release and the iPhone build installs with SideStore, with favourites cached for tunnels and dead zones.4
  • YouTube search and downloadsSave a song or a playlist of up to 200 entries, and follow channels that download new episodes by themselves.5
  • Synced lyrics you can correctLyrics come from the file, a .lrc beside it or online services, and anyone in the household can shift a line that runs early.6

Koel vs Melarka: specs side by side

Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.

Spec
PriceFree + PaidFree
LicenceMITAGPL-3.0
Web UIYesYes
iOSYesYes
AndroidYesYes
DockerYesYes
Linux package–Yes
Tech stackPHPGo
Docker Containers1 (app only)1 (app only)
DatabaseMySQLSQLite
Architecturex86 + ARMx86 + ARM

Common questions

Sources: Koel docs and Melarka site.

Updated