Dockmesh vs Portainer
Editor take
Choose Dockmesh for scheduled, verified backups, and for roles and SSO in the free build. Choose Portainer for Kubernetes and Podman, and for a release line since 2016.
Where they differ
Only what is true of one of them and not the other. Each app's weak spots are the other app's strengths.
Dockmesh
Where Dockmesh is stronger
- Scheduled, verified backupsBacks up stacks, volumes or the whole server to local disk, S3, SFTP, SMB or WebDAV, encrypted with age and read back to verify; Portainer's backup keeps only its own database and stack files.1
- Roles, SSO and an audit logOIDC, SAML, LDAP and OAuth2 sign-in with group mapping, roles assigned per host or stack, and an audit log, all in the free build; Portainer's equivalents need Business, free for up to 3 nodes.2
Portainer
Where Portainer is stronger
Dockmesh vs Portainer: specs side by side
Every spec for both apps in one table, so you can check install options, hardware and client apps before you pick one.
Common questions
Can Dockmesh replace Portainer?
For Compose stacks, yes: it covers stacks, containers, images, volumes, networks and agents. Portainer is still the one for Kubernetes and Swarm.
Does Portainer include single sign-on?
Yes, in Business Edition, which Portainer makes free for up to 3 nodes. Dockmesh has OIDC, SAML, LDAP and OAuth2 sign-in with group mapping, roles and an audit log in its open-source build.
Do remote hosts need an open port?
For Dockmesh, no: each agent dials the server over mTLS. A standard Portainer Agent needs port 9001 reachable from the server, while an Edge Agent, part of Portainer's Business Edition edge management, dials out and needs no open port.
Sources: Dockmesh docs and Portainer docs.